Jump to content

Money Exchange Rates - ATM vs. Bringing Cash


deleted

Recommended Posts

In my experience Kasikorn gives the best rate. Cheapest is to open an account, that will facilitate free withdrawal if in the province where your bank branch is located, or 15 Baht fee in another province. You can send from your home country direct by telegraphic transfer, which also provides the best rate of exchange. Good luck.

 

  A VISA card rate will usually always beat the TT bank rate by up to ~0.1B to the US dollar.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Visa costs 150 baht withdrawal fee, and the equivelant of 5 US$ from my account. That will be approx. 10US for every withdrawal of max 10000 Baht. Very bad deal for me. For a TT from my acount with no limit I pay approx 7 US and no more for the duration of my stay in LOS. If I use for ex. 300000 Baht you can quickly work out which method is best. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Visa costs 150 baht withdrawal fee, and the equivelant of 5 US$ from my account. That will be approx. 10US for every withdrawal of max 10000 Baht. Very bad deal for me. For a TT from my acount with no limit I pay approx 7 US and no more for the duration of my stay in LOS. If I use for ex. 300000 Baht you can quickly work out which method is best. 

 

Everyone has their own way of doing money. I'm lucky to have a Schwab debit card that gives me my baht at the best rate (or close) for no charge. I have a Kasikorn Bank account. I just did a 30k baht pull from a Krungsri ATM with my Schwab card and then deposited it in my Kasikorn account. 

 

I used to do transfers from my bank in the US to my Kasikorn account. But my bank charged US$40 (my bank charges more than some other banks) to do the transfer. Then I believe Kasikorn charges 500 baht on the Thai end (not sure about that)? I can do a lot of ATM pulls for US$40 + 500 baht on a trip (I don't live in Thailand just visit). And if the daily limit for the card can handle 20k-30k baht at a time then all the better. But no doubt the transfer is a good deal for some. Especially if you only have a card that can pull 10k baht a day and charges other fees.

 

BTW ATM use cost 180B these days and not 150B. Thai greed at it's finest...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just got back.  Man, its freaking hot out there.  I think its 37 in the Big Mango today and it feels like it April/May.  thats enough of a weather report....

 

Changes at Super Rich and got 36.02.  Just for shits and giggles I walked into another place right down the street.  Talked to the guy in charge and his English was pretty good, much better than your average Thai.  The rate there was 36.00.  He told me if I ever wanted to change more than $5k per day its not a problem.  I asked if he could give me a better rate for more than 5k and he said we can discuss it.

 

This other place is called Power Exchange web site  www.powerexchange.co.th.

 

I probably mentioned it before but there are staggering amount of cash in that Super Rich place.  I have seen big fat bricks of 1000 baht notes lying about on the desk ready to go out.  You can only imagine what they have in the back.  There has to be some serious money laundering going on or have I read too many drug dealer/intl criminal books books....

  • Upvote 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

 

Changes at Super Rich and got 36.02. 

 

This other place is called Power Exchange web site  www.powerexchange.co.th.

 

 

Looks like you got the best rate Arch, the one on the website that is Headquarters or Branch, NOT the Kiosk rate.

 

Power Exchange, that would be a good name for a Ladyboy Bar!

 

In Pattaya, TT Exchange seems to best rates of moneychangers that have multiple locations.

 

Can't find them online. Wonder what their rate is today?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Looks like you got the best rate Arch, the one on the website that is Headquarters or Branch, NOT the Kiosk rate.

 

Power Exchange, that would be a good name for a Ladyboy Bar!

 

In Pattaya, TT Exchange seems to best rates of moneychangers that have multiple locations.

 

Can't find them online. Wonder what their rate is today?

Hey PD where might I find a TT in central /south Patts ?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 months later...

atm.png

.. but it's ok that other foreigners are?  :notfair:

 

In my mind the existence of a pretty substantial fee from ATM withdrawals when using a foreign card make having a local Thai bank account even more worthwhile. If I were a regular visitor and didn't have one I would make serious strides to obtain one. 

 

As an expat I now have no ATM withdrawal charges. Only B20 if I use another Thai bank's ATM, but I don't.  Making quarterly transfers between my UK bank and Thai bank via the likes of TransferWise works very well for me.

 

Even carrying cash (must be declared to customs if $10,000 or over) and placing it into a local Thai bank on arrival in LoS would make sense.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree having a Thai acct is the way to go, on my trip last year I went to at least 10 branches :Kasikorn, Bangkok etc.. And none would give me one, something about needing to see proof of my residency or see a work permit (I forget now) but I finally gave up realizing it is nowhere near as easy to do it anymore

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Recently I found a 550 baht charge on my Kasikorn account from October when I wasn't in Thailand. It appears to be an ATM withdrawal unless ATM99001 is some secret code for some charge from K-Bank. I will try and find out what it is all about when I return to Thailand soon. If I don't get a satisfactory answer I may have to consider closing my account. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Recently I found a 550 baht charge on my Kasikorn account from October when I wasn't in Thailand. It appears to be an ATM withdrawal unless ATM99001 is some secret code for some charge from K-Bank. I will try and find out what it is all about when I return to Thailand soon. If I don't get a satisfactory answer I may have to consider closing my account.

Your right its a kasikorn annual charge everyone Kops it .

My guess is you originally opened your account in October , I opened my account in January that's when

they take it from me the anniversary of the date you opened the account .

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Your right its a kasikorn annual charge everyone Kops it .

My guess is you originally opened your account in October , I opened my account in January that's when

they take it from me the anniversary of the date you opened the account .

 

I think it's the annual charge for their ATM card.

 

If you have an account without an ATM card I don't think there is a charge.

 

So instead of closing your account at the beginning your trip, perhaps you can cancel your ATM card near the end of your trip.

 

Kasikorn does have a 50 baht monthly fee for accounts with less than 2000 baht so that's another thing to watch out for.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

For Yanks a pretty good option is doing an ACH transfer to Bangkok Bank in New York and the money is converted to baht in Thailand using the Telex Transfer (TT) rate which is better than the Cash or Traveller Check rate.

 

The fees for large transfer is $10 + 500 baht.

 

The sweet spot for small transfers is $1999 where the fee is $5 + 200 baht.

 

There is also World Remit.

 

I don't know too much about them because we only recently affiliated with them but the first transfer is free.

 

http://www.asiahotelandtravel.com/index.php/topic/434-transfering-money-overseas/

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

 

There is also World Remit.

 

I don't know too much about them because we only recently affiliated with them but the first transfer is free.

 

http://www.asiahotelandtravel.com/index.php/topic/434-transfering-money-overseas/

 

World Remit seems to work especially well for transfers to the Philippines as it appears that the receiptient doesn't even need a bank account.

 

 

Home delivery:                                 cash is delivered to the recipient’s home address (Philippines only).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

550B is kind of steep for the ATM card fee. And no I don't have the insurance. The statement says:

 

Transaction Type: Transfer Withdrawal NB

 

Withdrawal: 550.00

 

Service Channel: ATM ATM99001

 

If it is a legit charge some of my confusion comes from the fact I assumed it was an ATM transaction looking at the Service Channel. Can someone look at their statement and see what their statement says when paying their yearly fee? Maybe ATM99001 is some kind of code they use for bank charges. I also never see Transfer Withdrawal NB used as a transaction type on any other transactions. I don't want to go to the bank unless I need to as it's usually a PITA. Especially if you opened the account at the Pattaya Tai branch which is always seemingly busy.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If I click on the World Remit link I go to a page that gives me no info at all and has no links. It's a dead end. Do I have to create a login on that other site to see anything?

 

I will be pleasantly surprised to see any money transfer site that doesn't end up costing at least 2%.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 Can someone look at their statement and see what their statement says when paying their yearly fee? Maybe ATM99001 is some kind of code they use for bank charges. I also never see Transfer Withdrawal NB used as a transaction type on any other transactions. I don't want to go to the bank unless I need to as it's usually a PITA. Especially if you opened the account at the Pattaya Tai branch which is always seemingly busy.

 

I am looking at my newest Kasikorn bankbook which starts December 2013 to the present.

 

There is no annual fee.  

 

That might be cause I didn't want to pay extra for a card when my original one expired..  As I recall the card was a reasonable rate, 100 or 200 baht, but I really don't need the card as it's not my primary (or secondary) bank.

 

But I want to keep the account open as there could be a reason I want to use that account.

 

I foolishly let the account drop under 2000 baht and I incurred six monthly charges of 50 baht.

 

I have no code which starts with ATM in my book, I guess cause I don't have an ATM card so there can't be any ATM withdrawals or fees for an ATM card.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Found this PDF for Kasikorn charges: - http://www.kasikornbank.com/EN/RatesAndFees/Charges/ChargesDoc/FeeServices_06012016_en.pdf

 

All references to B550 are for annual card fees, for several different cards including K-Max, which is what I had/have.

 

This does make me glad I let Kasikorn go and changed to Bangkok Bank last year, they even pay interest.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If I click on the World Remit link I go to a page that gives me no info at all and has no links. It's a dead end. Do I have to create a login on that other site to see anything?

 

I will be pleasantly surprised to see any money transfer site that doesn't end up costing at least 2%.

 

First, click this link, posting it again for guys new to the thread:

 

http://www.asiahotelandtravel.com/index.php/topic/434-transfering-money-overseas/#entry970

 

Then

 

Way up top you choose the country you're sending from.

 

And on the left side middle the country you're sending to.

 

post-7348-0-99548800-1452296363_thumb.pn

 

Then click.

 

Then Yanks have to choose their state as they are only approved in about 45 states.  If you don't choose a state then everything is locked.

 

post-7348-0-80438600-1452296376_thumb.pn

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Found this PDF for Kasikorn charges: - http://www.kasikornbank.com/EN/RatesAndFees/Charges/ChargesDoc/FeeServices_06012016_en.pdf

 

All references to B550 are for annual card fees, for several different cards including K-Max, which is what I had/have.

 

This does make me glad I let Kasikorn go and changed to Bangkok Bank last year, they even pay interest.

 

Thanks DC. I guess that means I have a "K-Max Debit card" from the look of the fee info (and it says that on the card). Which pretty much sucks since I have the debt card part shut off. Next time I need to renew my card I will try for the straight ATM card and see how horribly that goes. 

 

Don't think I could get a BKK Bank account unless I apply for a retirement visa. And that would be way more trouble. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks DC. I guess that means I have a "K-Max Debit card" from the look of the fee info (and it says that on the card). Which pretty much sucks since I have the debt card part shut off. Next time I need to renew my card I will try for the straight ATM card and see how horribly that goes. 

 

Don't think I could get a BKK Bank account unless I apply for a retirement visa. And that would be way more trouble.

 

Have a look here:  http://www.bangkokbank.com/BangkokBank/PersonalBanking/SpecialServices/ForeignCustomers/Pages/Openinganaccountnew.aspx

 

Bangkok Bank - Opening an account:

 

In Thailand for a short time?        <==   :obscene: 

Even if you are only visiting Thailand for a relatively short period of time, you can open a savings account and get a debit card to use for shopping and ATM withdrawals. All you will need to provide is your passport and one other official identification document – for example, a reference letter from your embassy, your home bank or a person acceptable to the bank.

You will also need to provide evidence of your address in Thailand as well as your regular address in your home country.

Required Documents

Foreigner with Long-stay or Tourist Visa

Passport and one of the following documents:

2.1 An official document from another country, such as a document from the

relevant agency giving evidence of the customer’s right to receive pension

funds, OR a letter of reference from one of the following:

- Embassy or international organization

- Customer’s home bank to Bangkok Bank via the SWIFT messaging network

- Person acceptable to Bangkok Bank e.g. branch officer, customer, government officer or company executive

- Educational institution located in Thailand and acceptable to the bank

- Company that is acceptable to the bank, confirming the customer is in the process of getting a work permit

2.2 Other documents that show the name of the customer e.g. a document

showing the ownership of real estate in Thailand such as a unit in a

condominium

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...